Chapter 9-The Framing of Movies
Thoughts & Commentary on Media History
According to Social Photography by Lewis W. Hine, "To the range of advertising there is no limit, and where all are tooting the loud bazoo, the problem of any one making himself heard is no slight one. Advertising is art; it is literature; it is invention. Failure is its one cardinal sin".
"The social origins of motion pictures were a critical early influence on their path to development. Whereas newspapers and magazines had begun among the elite and evolved in a more popular direction, movies acquired a lowbrow image at an early point in their history and faced a challenge in achieving respectability."
This Nursery tales tells a story how different people around the city, gather together to fight for change in there city. The group of people going to tell the people of city of the trouble run into Mr. Boss, or in other words government who misleads them to a "machine" which he throws them into so they cannot warn the city.
In Flashes from the Slums, Jacob Riis a police reporter from 1888 leads around reporters from the New York Sun. These reporters are taking pictures in the evening and night. The purpose of this for Jacob Riis, was "besides the interest in taking of the pictures, was the collection of a series of views for magic lantern slides, showing, as no more description could, the misery and vice that he had noticed..."in the slums of New York City. (Riis) Riis' graphic images such as the Growler Gang to the left were a bunch of misplaced youths who would just drink their money away and would luckily find a place to stay overnight. Photographs such as this were used to persuade and engage "the emotions of society to make a social or olitical argument "that could "easily provoke strong feeling of outrage or sympathy" that could be used to facilitate social persuasion for the betterment of society. Other pictures that Riis features are of tenement houses and the "misery and destitution" of those who inhabit them. (Riis) This article by Riis and the photographs taken quickly became a powerful tool for "social reform and mass persuasion."
In Richard Connells' "All Wrong" a young man by the name of T.D. A. Marchbanks was visiting his Uncle in New York City for the very first time. Unfortunately, after his uncle had picked him up he had to run back to work so he would not get in trouble. He explains to Marchbanks that after he is done at the Custom House to take the Subway to Columbia University where he can meet him there. Amazingly, when Marchbanks gets on the subway he is scared to look around so he reads the numerous advertisements posted in the train. By the time he reads all of the advertisements he feels that all of these advertisements are true and happening to him simultaneously. So he becomes nervous and sick getting off the subway at Columbia University. It is there where he sees his last advertisement and the rest of his life flash away as he collapses and dies. Whats amazing about Connells' short story is the rate of advertising that was being done in the city and how overwhelming it could be for a man who has never seen it. Marchbanks actually felt that he was sick, losing his teeth, and had an pneumonia because of these advertisements because nobody had ever explained that they were just trying to persuade you to buy their products. Ultimately, Connels article depicts the power of the mass media and advertising business. It displays how a few advertisements and the sheer power of imagery can bring a man to his downfall.
The editor with the "White Sparks' is a text that shows the true form of the everyday happenings of a news room. In any form of mainstream media, integrity, truth, honesty, and good reporting can and will be compromised at times for the sake of money. People who have no experience will sometimes be the one who tell you how to do your job, and the truth is not always the most interesting or, even important thing when doing an editorial.
In the year 1912 "The civic use of motion picture had now been established", and with this new found way to grab peoples attention, many organizations used it as a chance to educate the common American. Motion pictures were being used to show the true story of child labor, prison labor, and even as an added assistant when electing new officials into office.
A police report by New York City authorities stated that “the conditions found to exist are such as to attach to cheap and impermanent places of amusement, to wit: poor sanitation, dangerous overcrowding, and inadequate protection from fire or panic. Despite the foul smells, poor ventilation, and frequent breakdowns in projection, investigators found overflow crowds in a majority of theaters.” According to Czitron. Some complained of the foul smells in the theaters that the manager would try to cover up with deodorizers and rowdy atmosphere which was actually everyday living conditions for the audience. “The darkness of the theater , argued some doctors and social workers, caused eye strain and related disorders: “Intense ocular and cerebral weariness, a sort of dazed ‘good-for-nothing’ feeling, lack of energy, or appetite, etc,” as one physician put it.” Czitrom.
In my opinion and prehaps in the opinions of many, the first amendment is if not the most, one of the most important amendment. Without this amendment that advocated freedom of speech , many of us would not be where we are today, in that sense communications and mass media would not exist. in the basic formulas of the equations that the mass media creates for individuals , includes freedom of speech. Without freedom of speech mass media would not exist. "It was during the progressive era, particularly between 1910 and 1917 that a free speech movement began to stir and writers and artists in rebellion against genteel culture discovered a common cause with radical dissenters on the left in the battle against censorship. A new Generation of young intellectuals , convinced that America's old Puritan "Hypocrisy stood in the way of honest understanding and full enjoyment of life, sought to open up discussion of sex, birth control, and forbidden subjects" (Starr pg 268). It is evident from the quote above presented from Paul Starr's "The Creation of the Media" that freedom of speech was something that many undoubtedly feared. it seems as if America was a country that lived by censorship. the act of censorship in my opinion creates a division among society, because many cater to the rules and regulations of censorship that our government feeds us while others rebel against censorship in society. in a sense i am glad that the first amendment was never destroyed..without it we just would be a society living for rebellion